Unease over Reliance Retail buyback offer
时间:2024-09-29 02:47:40 阅读(143)
The proposal of Reliance Industries (RIL) to buy back shares of Reliance Retail (RRL) is legal, but it hasn’t gone down well with a section of stakeholders who feel the company should have avoided a “forced buyout”.
Shriram Subramanian, founder and MD, InGovern Research Services, toldFE: “This is a forced buyout of minority shareholders of RRL by Reliance Retail Ventures (RRVL). The minority shareholders of RRL would be disappointed as the price is much lower than the current trading prices in the grey market.”
The buyback price was at a premium of Rs 477.97 and Rs 512.92 a share as determined by two independent valuers — E&Y and BDO Valuation Advisory — who valued it at Rs 884.03 and Rs 849.08 a share, respectively. RRVL, in which RIL holds an 85.06% stake, owns 99.93% in RRL. The other 7.86 million shares are with minority shareholders.
This capital reduction exercise with the shareholders getting cash in lieu of shares should easily sail through. While there have been no such moves by other large corporates, many small firms have done this at the time of delisting for promoters to own 100%, Subramanian said.
Shareholders who had either bought the shares from the grey market or employees who received them as stock options have no option but to accept the offer. The shares were trading at Rs 2,500-2,700 in the unlisted space. On conclusion of the offer, RIL will extinguish the shares.
MS Sahoo, distinguished professor at National Law University, Delhi, and former chairperson of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India, said it is a normal business strategy to buy back shares or reduce capital. “The law provides an elaborate process for this. There are checks and balances to ensure that no one is short-changed”. He said since Reliance Retail is an unlisted company, the exiting shareholders need to be paid as per valuation norms under the company law, not Sebi norms that apply to listed companies. The process requires shareholders’ approval by a special resolution and subsequent approval of the National Company Law Tribunal.
On the chances of retail shareholders objecting to the move, he said: “It is an unlisted firm with 99.9% of shares with promoters. Non-promoter shares are traded in the grey market, where price discovery is not transparent and liquidity is limited. It is, therefore, unlikely that non-promoter shareholders would resist the move, particularly when the proposed exit price is much higher than the minimum required under the law.”
Sahoo, however, said a buyback reduces the buffer available to creditors. “Therefore, it is not allowed when a company has outstanding debt, unless creditors agree or their interests are secured.”
上一篇:Sensex, Nifty battle volatility ahead of F&O expiry session; 5 things to know before opening bell
猜你喜欢
- Adani Enterprises, Infosys, NDTV, Aurobindo Pharma, Eicher Motors, Orient Cement, Dodla Dairy stocks in focus
- Adani Enterprises FPO fully subscribed on last day, bidding still open; shares rise over 3%
- Sensex rises 130 pts, Nifty above 17950 in early trade on Monday, Feb 20; HUL stock gains, Cipla shares fall 5%
- Sensex, Nifty erase gains, end lower amid high volatility, resistance at 16800; Bank Nifty support at 34800
- 18% GST on fees charged by Sebi
- TVS Motor Company rating- Buy - Delivering on margins yet again
- Across the aisle by P Chidambaram- Shutting out debate in talking shop
- Tech Mahindra shares tank 5% after Q1 earnings miss estimates; should you buy, sell or hold TechM stock-
- The sommelier’s conundrum- Pairing drinks with food that is zany and unprecedented will always be subjective exercise with as many opinions as there are diners in room